Thank you, Jennifer and team, for your really interesting and strong paper. Let me share some comments:
- Introduction: I would add:
o the possible endogeneity biases and how you addressed them
o possible pathways you tested
o main results (punctual estimations)
Also, I would probably move the literature review therein and make your contribution even clearer (e.g., I am not sure whether the novelty in your paper – in addition to the index – is the country or also that you considered “different stages in life”).
- Section 2:
o I would title “Context and data”
o 2.1 “The 1991-2002 Civil war in Sierra Leone” (Figure 1 should be shown in 2.3, as we still do not know about the definition of the conflict variable)
o 2.2 “Describing the Data”
o 2.3 “Defining conflict” (where you also show some desc stats on conflict data)
o 2.4 “Defining Labour Market Outcomes” (where you also show some desc stats on LMO). BTW, are the employment and LMP for any economic sectors? I would probably distinguish between sectors (wage, self-employment in agricultural and non-agricultural sectors) as the effect (and the pathways you identified) may differ.
o 2.5 “Defining the timing of key variables” (this is something is sparse in the paper, but would be better to have a clear description of the timing of your key variables (outcomes and conflict) to understand well how you set the causal relationship you estimate. Here, I would add I would add some non-parametric investigation of the relationship between the intensity of violence and your continuous outcomes
- Section 3:
o “Identifying the effect of conflict on LMO: empirical strategy”
o 3.1 “Econometric specification”
o 3.2 “Challenges to Identification”
- Sections 4 and 5 (current 6 and 7 are fine to me)
- Section 6: “Conclusions” (rather than 7c)
In the discussion of potential pathways (currect section 3), you identified two possible conflicting mechanisms (“discouragement” and “added worker” effects). You should try to link this discussion to your results more explicitly.
- Explain µ in the text
- This specification seems valid only for those who did not migrate (as “j” just indicates the place where he/she was born). Do you know exactly (year) when the person eventually migrated and where?
- I am not sure to understand why the reference cohort should be between 9 and 34
I generally liked the identification strategy. However:
- You state that the DDR helped some former soldiers to join the labour market. Might it have direct implications on the individuals you observed (if young/child soldiers)? Is the programme homogenous across the country?
- it seems excluding any possible “spill-over” effects. Is that a realistic assumption? (a village in conflict does not affect other villages in the country and, especially, its neighbouring villages).
- Related to this, I would control for a few more pre-conflict socio-economic (e.g., LMP at j level?) village variables (in its current specification, the model does not include any socio-economic variables which might affect more directly labour market outcomes).
- Also, removing migrants and compare the results (with and w/out migrants) is partially satisfactory. You probably do not have the exact time of migration and the new destination, so you cannot do better. But it should be said, as well as how many people migrated.
Table 2: col 5 and 6, control variables should be “yes”?
Table 6: why number of chiefdom just 39?
Results on wages: -2/0 and 0-3 seem having the largest impact here – contrarily from the employment/LMP estimates. Can this be explained that here, I guess, you just look at wage workers and not to all the labour force/employees? If so, I would reiterate my suggestion to also run sectorial estimations for the employment/LMP
- IV: please say more about the “measure of quality of education”. Also, a few lines on the Wooldridge (2002) would be probably necessary.
- You state that education is the main impact pathway. However, it seems that this is the real impact mechanism you tested.
Table 8: please add a note for each specification.
Impact pathways. E.g., I would also look at, if available:
o Psycological-stress related variables
o Family assets
o Supply/demand side variables affecting employment and wages?
- ↳ Gender analysis
- ↳ Child poverty
- ↳ Employment
- ↳ Poverty
- ↳ Community-based monitoring systems (CBMS)
- ↳ CGE & macro-micro policy modelling (MPIA)
- ↳ Microeconomics & distributive analysis (PMMA)
- ↳ Experimental research (PIERI)
- General information
- ↳ about PEP
- ↳ about this forum
- ↳ MPIA
- ↳ Politiques Agricoles, emploi et revenu des femmes au Burkina Faso – MPIA 20094
- ↳ L’impact de l’APE sur le travail décent des femmes: Quelle contribution des investissements publics? Une analyse en EGC Dynamique appliquée au cas du Sénégal – MPIA 19999
- ↳ Réformes agricoles, emploi et réduction de la pauvreté: une analyse en EGC dynamique – MPIA 20006
- ↳ Commodity Booms, Human Capital, and Economic Growth. An Application to Colombia – MPIA 20108
- ↳ The impact of fiscal reforms on poverty and income distribution in Tanzania: Macro-micro simulation modelling – MPIA 19971
- ↳ Resource allocation across industrial sectors, poverty and income inequality in Ethiopia: CGE modelling approach – MPIA 20030
- ↳ Assessment of the welfare, employment and gender impacts of policy options for renewable energy financing in Nigeria – MPIA 20261
- ↳ Assessing Macroeconomic Impact of Skill Development Programme in India: A CGE Analysis – MPIA 20232
- ↳ Simulating Impact of China-Pakistan Economic Corridor on Growth, Employment and Poverty in Pakistan – MPIA 20170
- ↳ Post-conflict and rural income in Colombia – MPIA 20290
- ↳ Exchange rate policy in a dollarized economy: Implications on growth and employment in Bolivia – MPIA 20260
- ↳ Can a Wage Subsidy be used to Improve Women’s Formal Employment in Zambia? – MPIA 20242
- ↳ Identifying Key Policy Options for Growth and Gainful Employment in Ghana – MPIA 20234
- ↳ Institutionalisation project for Mongolia - MPIA-19906
- ↳ PIERI
- ↳ The Impacts of Access to Free Childcare on Women’s Labor Market Outcomes and Children’s Cognitive Development – PIERI 13129
- ↳ Impact des Modèles Innovants de Conseil Agricole et d’Entrepreneuriat des Jeunes sur la Résilience et la Sécurité Alimentaire des Ménages au Bénin : Une Approche basée sur les Essais Aléatoires Contrôlés – PIERI 13014
- ↳ Stimulating SME performance and recovery in the aftermath of the Ebola crisis: Evidence from a business training intervention in Liberia – PIERI 12937
- ↳ Academic Ambassadors and the Diffusion of Digital Financial Services among the peruvian poor – PIERI 12942
- ↳ Can Mobile Money Induce Entrepreneurial and Financial Behaviors of Members of Village Savings and Loan Associations in Rural Southern Malawi? – PIERI 20281
- ↳ Extending Financial Access To The Poor: Evidence From Gambia – PIERI 20165
- ↳ Overcoming Constraints on Labor Force Entry – PIERI 20211
- ↳ Microfinance and intra-household decision making: An experimental study in rural Cambodia – PIERI 20208
- ↳ PMMA
- ↳ Financial inclusion and gender disparity in risk appetite for micro, small and medium enterprises performance: Evidence from Ethiopia – PMMA 19978
- ↳ Rural nonfarm engagement and agriculture commerciali-zation in Ghana: complements or competitors? – PMMA 19983
- ↳ Labor force participation for educated females and gender wage gap in Palestine – PMMA 20015
- ↳ Cognitive skills, entrepreneurship, and economic growth in Indonesia – PMMA 20026
- ↳ Non-farm participation, agriculture productivity and farmers welfare in East-Africa – PMMA 20055
- ↳ Gender pay gap in times of austerity – PMMA 20000
- ↳ Youth unemployment and transition from School to work in Benin – PMMA 20083
- ↳ Informal employment and labor market policies. The case of domestic workers in Uruguay – PMMA 20102
- ↳ Examining the Impact of Early Childbearing on Labor Market Outcomes – Research Fellows
- ↳ Gender and Age Diversity to Forster Innovation and Productivity Growth – PMMA 20201
- ↳ Do out-migration and remittances induce shifts to non-farm entrepreneurship among the left-behind? Evidence from Nepal – PMMA 20166
- ↳ Access to child care and mothers’ employment quality: lessons from Chile – PMMA 20279
- ↳ Migration, Remittances and Child Schooling in Rural Cambodia – PMMA 20209
- ↳ Analysis of youth underemployment in Macedonia, Montenegro and Serbia – PMMA 19985
- ↳ Employment vulnerability, earnings and subjective well-being in Kyrgyzstan – PMMA 20167
- ↳ Understanding youth entrepreneurship in Benin: the role of microcredit uptake and entrepreneur capacity building – PMMA 20272
- ↳ Can urbanization improve household welfare and provide inclusive opportunities? The case of urban expansion in Ethiopia – PMMA 20210
- ↳ Occupational preferences and labour market skills mismatch among youth in Zambia – PMMA 20280
- ↳ Civil conflict and labor market outcomes in Sierra Leone – PMMA 20257
- ↳ CBMS
- ↳ Incorporating Gender Dimension in Policy Research
- ↳ Defining and Measuring Equity in Opportunity
- ↳ Local Governance
- ↳ Determinants of Youth Unemployment and Labour Market Transition in Botswana
- ↳ Determinants of Financial Inclusion for Youth Entrepreneurship: Evidences from Addis Ababa and Shirka Wereda, Ethiopia
- ↳ Does addressing gender inequalities and empowering women improve development programme outcomes? The Case of C:AVA project in Ghana
- ↳ Social Capital and Women’s Empowerment in Kenya: Case Study of Murang’a County
- ↳ Understanding the Challenges of Financial Inclusion of Rural Women’s Entrepreneurship
- ↳ Agricultural investments, labor productivity and rural poverty reduction: gender disparities in Togo
- ↳ A Livelihood Approach to Understand Financial Inclusion as informed by the Community Based Monitoring System (CBMS) Study in Katakwi Sub-County of Katakwi District
- ↳ SDG Report of Botswana
- ↳ SDG Report of CBMS Ethiopia Project Site (Addis Ababa Sub City, Wereda 10)
- ↳ Localizing the Sustainable Development Goals in Ghana using the CBMS
- ↳ SDG Profile of Gikindu Location, Murang’a County Kenya
- ↳ Monitoring Poverty in rural Nicaragua through the Community Based Monitoring System: A SDGs and MPI report
- ↳ Analysis of SDG’s indicators and Poverty Profile of Danyi Attigba-Elavagnon, Dalave and Gblainvie township at Togo
- ↳ Community Response to Localisation of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): A profile on relevant Indicators
- 2019 PEP Annual Conference
- ↳ MPIA
- ↳ MPIA-20242 - Can a Wage Subsidy be used to Improve Women’s Formal Employment in Zambia?
- ↳ MPIA-20234 - Identifying key policy options for growth and gainful employment in Ghana
- ↳ MPIA-20261 - Assessment of the welfare, employment and gender impacts of policy options for renewable energy financing in Nigeria
- ↳ MPIA-20290 - Post-conflict and rural income in Colombia
- ↳ MPIA-20260 - Exchange rate policy in a dollarized economy: Implications on growth and employment in Bolivia
- ↳ MPIA-19906 - Institutionalisation project for Mongolia
- ↳ PIERI
- ↳ PIERI-20281 - Can Mobile Money Induce Entrepreneurial and Financial Behaviors of Members of Village Savings and Loan Associations in Rural Southern Malawi?
- ↳ PIERI-20165 - Extending Financial Access To The Poor: Evidence From Gambia
- ↳ PIERI-13129 - The Impacts of Access to Free Childcare on Women's Labor Market Outcomes and Children's Cognitive Development
- ↳ PIERI-13014 - Impact des Modèles Innovants de Conseil Agricole et d'Entrepreneuriat des Jeunes sur la Résilience et la Sécurité Alimentaire des Ménages au Bénin
- ↳ PIERI-12937 - Stimulating SME performance and recovery in the aftermath of the Ebola crisis: Evidence from a busine
- ↳ PIERI-12942 - Academic Ambassadors and the Diffusion of Digital Financial Services among the peruvian poor
- ↳ PMMA
- ↳ PMMA-20201 - Gender and Age Diversity to Foster Innovation and Productivity Growth
- ↳ PMMA-20166 - Do out-migration and remittances induce shifts to non-farm entrepreneurship among the left-behind? Evidence from Nepal
- ↳ Research Fellows - Examining the impact of early childbearing on education, literacy and labour market outcomes in seven developing countries
- ↳ PMMA-20209 - Migration, Remittances and Child Schooling in Rural Cambodia
- ↳ PMMA-20167 - Employment vulnerability, earnings and subjective well-being in Kyrgyzstan
- ↳ PMMA-20257 - Civil conflict and labor market outcomes in Sierra Leone
- ↳ PMMA-20210 - Can Urbanization Improve Household Welfare and Provide Inclusive Opportunities? The Case of Urban Expansion in Ethiopia
- ↳ PMMA-20272 - Understanding youth entrepreneurship in Benin: the role of microcredit uptake and entrepreneur capacity building
- ↳ Research Fellows - Examining the Impact of Early Childbearing on Education, Labor Force Participation and Earnings in Brazil
- ↳ PMMA-20280 - Occupational Preferences and Labour Market Skills Mismatch among Youths in Zambia
- ↳ PMMA-20279 - Access to child care and mothers' employment quality: lessons from Chile
- ↳ CBMS
- ↳ Government IE Mentoring
- 2019 PEP Special General Meeting
- ↳ MPIA
- ↳ MPIA-20391 - Impact des investissements publics sur l’emploi et la productivité des femmes dans les secteurs agricoles et non agricoles dans un contexte de dépendance économique aux ressources naturelles : Cas de la RDC.
- ↳ MPIA-20398 - Analyse par un modèle d’équilibre général calculable de l’impact de la stratégie d’investissement 2019-2023 du Sénégal dans les secteurs moteurs sur la participation au marché du travail et l’emploi des femmes et des jeunes et le bien être de
- ↳ MPIA-20419 - Adaptation au Changement climatique, genre et la pauvreté au Burkina Faso: une analyse macro-micro
- ↳ MPIA-20453 - Politique d’emploi et File d’attente sur le marché du travail : cas du Sénégal
- ↳ MPIA-20397 - The Impacts of Electrification on Employment, Poverty, and Gender in Nigeria
- ↳ MPIA-20414 - Public Investment on National Food Security Programs in Nigeria: A CGE Analysis of the Macroeconomic, Welfare and Gender Impact on Small Farm Holders in Nigeria.
- ↳ MPIA-20426 - Financial inclusion and women investment in low-income countries
- ↳ MPIA-20448 - Assessing the economic and social impacts of the Nigerian rural electrification project using a gender computable general equilibrium model
- ↳ MPIA-20452 - CGE-microsimulation analysis of government infrastructure investment and interventions in South African rural economy: focus on rural economic development, food security, poverty and gender
- ↳ MPIA-20456 - Investments in the agricultural sector and poverty reduction in Guinea-Bissau: an analysis with CGE model
- ↳ PMMA
- ↳ PMMA-20386 - The gender gap in smallholder agricultural productivity: The case of Cameroon
- ↳ PMMA-20395 - The impact of non-farm income on livelihoods in rural Zimbabwe: A gendered perspective
- ↳ PMMA-20460 - Programme de Microcrédit aux Plus Pauvres et autonomisation des femmes en milieu rural au Bénin: Une approche quasi-expérimentale
- ↳ PMMA-20443 - Credit constraints, agricultural productivity and household welfare in Burkina Faso: a gender perspective
- ↳ PMMA-20428 - The unintended consequences of the Malawi Farm Input Subsidy Programme (FISP): Women's entrepreneurship and financial inclusion.
- ↳ PMMA-20429 - L'inclusion financiere promeut-elle le genre de l'entrepreneur au Benin ?
- ↳ PMMA-20418 - Women's Employment Issue in Rural Senegal: What Can We Learn About the Shift From Farm Activities to Diversification Strategies?
- ↳ PMMA-20449 - The role of non-farming activities on rural farming households in Lesotho: a gender perspective
- ↳ PMMA-20454 - Electrification rurale, autonomisation de la femme et bien-être du ménage en milieu rural en Côte D'Ivoire
- ↳ PMMA-20396 - Accessing finance for productive rural employment opportunities for women in Benin
- ↳ Government IE Mentoring
- Research Fellows
- ↳ Research Fellows
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest